C2 · Grammar · Seltene und literarische Formen
Rare German Forms: Konjunktiv I in Wishes, Genitive Objects, Archaic Word Order
The ruleA handful of constructions survive only in law, liturgy, proverbs and literature: recognition is required, production almost never is.
Everything in this topic is dead or dying in ordinary German and entirely alive in the texts a C2 reader is expected to handle. None of it needs to enter your active range; all of it needs to stop being an obstacle.
Konjunktiv I outside reported speech
The optative: a wish or an instruction expressed with the bare subjunctive. It survives in fixed phrases, in mathematical and technical prose, and in liturgy.
| Phrase | Means | Where you meet it |
|---|---|---|
| Es lebe die Freiheit! | Long live freedom! | Slogans, toasts |
| Gott sei Dank. | Thank God. | Frozen, everyday |
| Sei es, wie es sei. | Be that as it may. | Written |
| Man nehme drei Eier. | Take three eggs. | Old recipes |
| Sei x eine reelle Zahl. | Let x be a real number. | Mathematics: fully alive |
| Es werde Licht. | Let there be light. | Biblical |
The mathematical use is the only productive one left. A German textbook proof still opens Sei G eine Gruppe, and it is not archaic there at all.
Verbs with a genitive object
Once a full class, now perhaps two dozen verbs, nearly all confined to legal and elevated written German.
| Verb | Means | Example |
|---|---|---|
| sich einer Sache bedienen | to make use of | Er bediente sich eines Tricks. |
| jemanden einer Tat beschuldigen | to accuse of | Man beschuldigte ihn des Diebstahls. |
| sich einer Sache bewusst sein | to be aware of | Ich bin mir des Problems bewusst. |
| einer Sache bedürfen | to require | Das bedarf keiner Erklärung. |
| jemanden einer Sache verdächtigen | to suspect of | Sie verdächtigten ihn des Betrugs. |
| sich einer Sache enthalten | to abstain from | Er enthielt sich der Stimme. |
| einer Sache gedenken | to commemorate | Wir gedenken der Opfer. |
sich bewusst sein is the one that is genuinely current: Ich bin mir dessen bewusst is ordinary careful German. The rest belong to courtrooms and commemorations.
Older word order and dropped forms
- Hat er das Buch, das er gestern gekauft, schon gelesen? Has he read the book he bought yesterday? Dropped auxiliary in a relative clause: normal in older prose, still seen in careful writing.
- Ich weiß nicht, ob er kommen wird können. I don't know whether he'll be able to come. Future plus double infinitive: grammatical, avoided by everyone.
- Es war ein Mann, der hatte drei Söhne. There was a man who had three sons. Main-clause order after a relative pronoun: folk-tale style.
- Der Sonne Licht the light of the sun Preposed genitive: poetic only; ordinary German is das Licht der Sonne.
Forms in retreat
| Form | Status | Replacement |
|---|---|---|
| One-word Konjunktiv II of strong verbs: de|käme, ginge, führe | Written, receding | würde + Infinitiv |
| Genitive after de|wegen, trotz, während | Standard in writing, lost in speech | Dative |
| ward (preterite of de|werden) | Archaic | wurde |
| dünken, gereichen, obliegen | Legal and literary | Ordinary verbs |
| derselbe / desselben as a pronoun | Bureaucratic, criticised | er, sie, es |
Where it goes wrong
Ich bin mir des Problem bewusst.
Ich bin mir des Problems bewusst.
If you are going to use a genitive object at all, the noun still needs its genitive -s. Half-formed elevated register is more conspicuous than plain German would have been, which is the general lesson of this topic.
Common questions
Is Konjunktiv I still used outside reported speech?
Only in fixed expressions and in mathematics. 'Es lebe …', 'Gott sei Dank' and 'Man nehme …' are frozen; 'Sei x eine reelle Zahl' is fully productive in mathematical writing and not archaic at all in that context.
Which German verbs take a genitive object?
Around two dozen, nearly all formal: sich bedienen, bedürfen, gedenken, beschuldigen, verdächtigen, sich enthalten, sich bewusst sein. Only the last is common in ordinary careful German: 'Ich bin mir dessen bewusst'.
Do I need to produce these forms at C2?
No. C2 asks you to read and understand them without hesitation, and to recognise the register they belong to. Producing them outside their proper context is a stronger marker of non-nativeness than avoiding them.
Next