B2 · Grammar · Konzessivsätze
German Concessive Clauses: obwohl, trotzdem, trotz, dennoch
The ruleThe meaning is the same in all four; the grammar is not: obwohl subordinates, trotzdem and dennoch are adverbs, and trotz is a preposition with the genitive.
The four forms
| Word | Class | Word order | Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| obwohl | Subordinating | Verb last | Obwohl es regnete, gingen wir spazieren. |
| trotzdem | Adverb | Verb second | Es regnete. Trotzdem gingen wir spazieren. |
| dennoch / jedoch | Adverb, formal | Verb second | Es regnete; dennoch gingen wir spazieren. |
| trotz | Preposition + genitive | No clause at all | Trotz des Regens gingen wir spazieren. |
| aber | Coordinating | Nothing changes | Es regnete, aber wir gingen spazieren. |
All five sentences mean the same thing. Choosing between them is a matter of register and rhythm: obwohl and aber in speech, dennoch and trotz in formal writing.
obwohl, obgleich, obschon
obwohl is the everyday one. obgleich and obschon mean exactly the same and are literary; you should recognise them and need not use them. All three send the verb to the end.
- Obwohl er müde war, arbeitete er weiter. Although he was tired, he kept working. Concessive clause first: the main verb follows the comma directly.
- Er arbeitete weiter, obwohl er müde war. He kept working although he was tired. Same sentence, clause second.
trotz takes the genitive
And is followed by a noun, not a clause, so any verb has to be nominalised first. That transformation is itself a B2 skill.
| Clause | Prepositional phrase |
|---|---|
| obwohl es regnete | trotz des Regens |
| obwohl er krank war | trotz seiner Krankheit |
| obwohl sie sich bemühten | trotz ihrer Bemühungen |
trotz with the dative (trotz dem Regen) is widespread in speech and non-standard in writing. The fixed phrase trotz allem is a dative and is correct.
Concession with a wh-word
However / no matter how is built with auch and a subjunctive-flavoured word order, or with egal.
- Wie sehr er sich auch bemühte, es klappte nicht. However hard he tried, it didn't work. Formal.
- Egal, wie sehr er sich bemühte, es klappte nicht. No matter how hard he tried, it didn't work. Everyday.
- Was auch immer passiert, ich bleibe. Whatever happens, I'm staying.
Where it goes wrong
Obwohl es regnete, trotzdem gingen wir spazieren.
Obwohl es regnete, gingen wir spazieren.
One concessive marker per sentence. obwohl has already done the work, and adding trotzdem doubles it: the German equivalent of writing although … nevertheless in one breath.
Common questions
What is the difference between obwohl and trotzdem?
Grammar, not meaning. obwohl is a subordinating conjunction and sends its verb to the end. trotzdem is an adverb that takes first position, so the verb comes second and the subject third. Using trotzdem with verb-final order is a standard error.
Does trotz take the genitive or the dative?
The genitive in standard German: trotz des Regens, trotz der Kälte. The dative is very common in speech and is still treated as non-standard in writing, with the exception of the fixed phrase trotz allem.
How do I say 'no matter how' in German?
Colloquially with egal wie: 'Egal, wie sehr er sich bemüht.' In formal writing, with the wh-word plus auch: 'Wie sehr er sich auch bemühte.' Both are concessive and neither needs obwohl.
Next